Verified Client Reviews

What Ohio Home Buyers and Sellers Say About Amanda Mullins

Amanda Mullins holds a 5.0 star rating across Google, RateMyAgent, and FastExpert. These are real, verified reviews from buyers, sellers, and relocating families across central and southwest Ohio. No scripts, no incentives, no filters.

5.0
49+ verified reviews
Google  ·  RateMyAgent  ·  FastExpert
Ratings by Platform
Google Reviews
5.0 ★★★★★
RateMyAgent
5.0 ★★★★★
FastExpert
5.0 ★★★★★
Zillow
5.0 ★★★★★
RateMyAgent Agent of the Year 2026 Champaign County RateMyAgent Top 5 Clark County 2026
5.0Avg Star Rating
49+Verified Reviews
100%5-Star Reviews
10Ohio Counties Served
Amanda Mullins is a 5-star rated REALTOR with eXp Realty serving central and southwest Ohio. She holds a 5.0 star rating across Google, RateMyAgent, and FastExpert with 49+ verified reviews. Clients consistently cite her communication, market knowledge, appraisal management background, and commitment to going above and beyond as differentiators. She was recognized as RateMyAgent Agent of the Year for Champaign County 2026 and ranked Top 5 in Clark County 2026.
Jacob C.
★★★★★
Buyer

"I cannot recommend Amanda highly enough! She is very intelligent and equally as kind and supportive. Amanda is extremely skilled and good at what she does. I learned so much from her and felt how much she genuinely wanted to help us. Amanda was accessible, easy to work with and excellent communication. Made each step feel manageable, centered on our humanity first. Overall best possible outcome working with Amanda!"

Zeke S.
★★★★★
First-Time Buyer

"I HIGHLY recommend Amanda Mullins to any first time home buyers. My wife and I recently closed on our first house due in large part to Amanda. She is an absolute professional, always keeping the client's best interest in mind, and going above and beyond to make sure we were satisfied. She's personable and extremely approachable with any and all questions throughout the homebuying process."

Heidi E.
★★★★★
Investment Property

"Amanda's professionalism, knowledge of the market, and genuine care for our needs made buying our investment property possible. We had a very difficult purchase and Amanda walked us through every turn in the road. She helped us negotiate the best price, we won the bidding war because of her wisdom, coordinated the inspections, and reassured us during the stressful moments. Amanda's integrity AND expertise AND kindness made our purchase possible."

Skylar P.
★★★★★
Buyer

"Couldn't say enough good things about Amanda. She stuck with us every step of the way and went above and beyond through a very complicated purchase. An amazing agent and person who really cares about her clients."

Lisa P.
★★★★★
Buyer

"If you want a RE agent that will be 150% devoted to you, then look no further. My daughter would not be moving into her new home if it weren't for Amanda's dedication and commitment to the process. We had a bumpy road between financing and a difficult seller, but Amanda stuck with us and fought for us every step of the way. I could never express enough how amazing Amanda is."

Aaron E.
★★★★★
Buyer

"Buying a house is not an easy task! There are so many behind the scenes issues that Amanda helped and supported us with. The process took longer than expected but we got through it together! Thank you for the tenacity and empathy throughout the entire process!"

Rachel P.
★★★★★
Seller

"Amanda's the best! She's super responsive, knowledgeable, and was there every step of the way when I was selling my home. She provided exceptional guidance, support, and is a very lovely human. Would highly recommend."

Matthew C.
★★★★★
Seller

"Amanda is a phenomenal realtor and I highly recommend her services! She helped us immensely during the process of selling our home and made it as easy as possible. She's very knowledgeable and knows what she's doing. Amanda is such a kind and compassionate person and you can tell she genuinely cares about her clients."

Evan B.
★★★★★
First-Time Buyer

"Amanda was very knowledgeable and helpful throughout the entire process of purchasing our first home. We can't recommend her enough! She was always readily available if we had any questions and was thoughtful and upfront about every concern we had."

Terry S.
★★★★★
Buyer

"Amanda was amazing. Prompt to respond, always willing to answer my questions, made suggestions along the way and kept me updated on any new developments. Would definitely recommend using her for all your realty needs!"

Jace M.
★★★★★
First-Time Buyer

"I was a young buyer and never struggled to be taken seriously. Extremely quick responses and great communication! If I wanted to see a house, I was able to be shown the house the same day or next at the very latest, typically within a couple hours of the request. It was an absolute dream working with Amanda! Would highly recommend to anyone looking for a fantastic realtor!"

Carl R.
★★★★★
Nonprofit Purchase

"I worked with Amanda as she helped a brand new nonprofit organization purchase a building for their ministry. It was a complicated purchase and she exceeded all of our expectations in terms of dedication and professionalism. She was extremely helpful. I highly recommend Amanda for your real estate needs."

Risner L.
★★★★★
Buyer

"Amanda is one of the best Realtors I have ever known. She helped me buy my house in a quick time. She was always available to help, even after the process was done. She is so nice."

Gertrude F.
★★★★★
First-Time Buyer

"As a first time buyer, I didn't know much about the process. She educated me about each step, provided honest advice on property values, connected me to the right people, and was incredibly communicative. Her strategy during the negotiation phase was impressive. She provided support beyond the closing, scheduling repair companies, utilities, moving, etc. Her dedication to my satisfaction was evident. You are exceptionally awesome!"

Dana N.
★★★★★
First-Time Buyer

"You can tell she has many years of experience as she was very knowledgeable and helped us throughout the entire process. She was very prompt in her communication and we never had any issues that she couldn't figure out or get resolved for us. We definitely would not have survived the process of getting our first house without her help. If you are looking for a realtor that cares, is invested in your best interest, and passionate about their job, look no further."

Amber L.
★★★★★
Buyer

"Exceptional patience and responsiveness were the driving force behind our successful home-buying experience. They took the time to understand our needs and preferences and provided a variety of options that met our requirements. Their knowledge of the local real estate market was impressive, and their guidance was invaluable in helping us make informed decisions. They were always available to answer our questions and their professionalism and reliability were second to none."

Larry W.
★★★★★
Buyer

"Simply amazing! The real estate knowledge is second to none. They will share their knowledge and expertise with you to help you make the best and most beneficial decisions during your home buying or selling process. You absolutely can't go wrong!"

Michelle S.
★★★★★
Buy and Sell

"A true 5 star experience! They are an amazing group of professionals who truly made the process of selling and buying a home as easy as possible. Hardworking, honest, patient and always available when we needed them. We were updated on a regular basis, never left any questions unanswered and they went above and beyond problem-solving any obstacles along the way."

Josh L.
★★★★★
Buy and Sell

"Whenever I had any questions, concerns, or needed any advice Amanda was always there for me. Both were extremely knowledgeable in many areas and made my buying and selling process extremely smooth. Seriously cannot recommend them enough!"

Brigette T.
★★★★★
Estate Sale

"A big thank you for being our agents on the sale of my mom's home. They were always readily available and helpful, with the right advice on what needed to be addressed to prepare the home for market. We had a bidding war and were happy with the outcome of the sale!"

Dawn H.
★★★★★
Relocation

"Amanda was referred for my mom's search for a home on Indian Lake. My mom lives 3.5 hours away, doesn't email, speaks English as a second language. None of this ever seemed to phase Amanda as she patiently arranged virtual showings and scheduled in-person visits juggling a variety of schedules. Because of her support and expertise, we recently closed on a home. I will forever cheerlead for Amanda because she helped make a dream come true for our family."

Sherry V.
★★★★★
Relocation from Tennessee

"We were moving from Tennessee and they were so accommodating. They spent many hours and traveled further than normal to find us our beautiful home. So knowledgeable and got to know us and the things we didn't like. They made sure to let us know when we wouldn't like certain places, and they were right! If there is ever another move, I'd definitely choose them."

Michael B.
★★★★★
Buyer

"Amanda is an amazing agent and delightful person to have on your team. She has proven herself time and time again with delivering consistent, professional, and tailored care to each conversation and transaction. Amanda provides a truly honest and caring effort with each interest and idea, sharing her personal thoughts and experience so you make the very best decision in your endeavors. I highly recommend Amanda!"

Nikki T.
★★★★★
First-Time Buyer

"Five stars and then some! If you are looking to purchase a home I cannot recommend them enough! They truly care! They go above and beyond. As this being my first experience with home buying, I really learned a lot from them. They were always available to answer any questions. They made me feel very comfortable and at ease. I also feel like I gained new friends in the process!"

Sadrac D.
★★★★★
Client

"I have had the best experience ever. From day one they made me feel special, not like a simple client to them. Unfortunately I wish I could give you more stars. You are the best agents I have met so far. Stay blessed."

Had a great experience with Amanda?

Your review helps other Ohio home buyers and sellers find the right agent. It takes less than two minutes and means the world to a small business owner who lives and breathes this community.